Judgement Delivered: CMA Members victorious over KZNA

Share:

The High Court judgement in the Comrades Marathon Association (CMA) Members versus KwaZulu Natal Athletics (KZNA) has just been delivered. CMA Members have won with costs. The High Court found that KZNA acted unlawfully when it attempted to restrict CMA membership and voting rights to people domiciled in KwaZulu-Natal via Steve Mkasi’s “locals only” edict.

Mkasi has subsequently been removed as KZNA president after harassing, stalking and getting involved in street brawl with a local race organiser. Mkasi’s “locals only” edict was seen by many, including this author, as an attempt to capture the Comrades Marathon. The costs ruling is going to leave KZNA with a hefty bill to pay.

Attorney Mark Leathers has confirmed his portion of the costs will be going to charity. After the initial Urgent High Court Interdict, Leathers was elected onto the CMA Board and subsequently became the Chair of the Comrades Marathon Association.

The ruling effectively cements the independence of the Comrades Marathon. It also has far reaching implications for all sporting events and sports bodies in South Africa who now have a High Court ruling allowing them to go independent if they so wish and protecting them from the nefarious attentions of corrupt, compromised and inept sporting bodies.

Huge congratulations and massive thanks to Mark Leathers, Cas Pretorius and team – and to those brave enough to stand up to tyranny and corruption to protect a national treasure!

The full judgement and an AI summary are provided below.

This is the important bit – CMA Members win with costs.

AI Generated Judgement Summary

This is a decisive victory for the 62 members of the Comrades Marathon Association (CMA) who challenged KwaZulu-Natal Athletics (KZNA). The High Court found that KZNA acted unlawfully when it attempted to restrict CMA membership and voting rights to people domiciled in KwaZulu-Natal.

The key findings were:

  • CMA membership is not geographically restricted. The court held that ASA/KZNA’s domicile rule applies to athletes and athletics participation structures, not to ordinary CMA membership.
  • CMA is independent of KZNA in its internal affairs. KZNA has no lawful or constitutional authority to dictate CMA’s membership, governance, policies or procedures.
  • KZNA’s attempt to turn out-of-province CMA members into non-voting observers or volunteers unlawfully stripped them of established membership rights. The relevant KZNA resolutions were therefore reviewed and set aside.
  • The court found that KZNA’s Executive Board did not have the authority to pass a resolution interfering with CMA members’ rights.
  • Importantly, the court regarded KZNA’s decision as administrative action subject to judicial review under PAJA, because KZNA exercises regulatory functions in athletics and its decision had an immediate external effect on members’ rights.
  • The judgment was particularly critical of KZNA’s procedural conduct, including late filings and an incomplete review record, and ordered KZNA to pay the applicants’ legal costs, including two counsel, with senior counsel’s fees on the punitive Scale C.

In plain English: KZNA tried to remove the voting and governance rights of CMA members who live outside KZN. The court said it had no power to do so, confirmed that CMA controls its own membership and governance, restored the affected members’ rights, and made KZNA pick up the legal bill.

The CMA Members who Stood Up to Tyranny

In a post on his Facebook account (https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1EE8nsrKEg/), Mark Leathers listed and thanked all the CMA Members who signed a special power of attorney so the case could be brought in their name:

Robin Jeremy Archer, A Ashworth, D Ashworth, B Beckerleg, DM Borain, T Borain, C Botha, FS Botha, Patricia Anne Botton, DB Boustead, T Boyles, Fiona Braithwaite, R Brayley, Mervyn Ernest Bremmer, Jan-Rudolph Buhrmann, S Burnett, L Calenborne, L Calitz, Greig Andre Campbell, E Chinniah, Claire Jane Conchor, Grant Cowen, H Cox, Robert Michael Craig, S Crooks, EL Da Silva, IF Davids, Peter Arie Charles De Groot, J Dinkel, G Du Bourg, M Du Plessis, M Dumasi, L Edgcumbe, M Edgcumbe, Juan Eekhout, Deon Izak Ehlers, M Evans, MI Fehrsen, B Fordyce, Antonio Gambino, G Gibson, Andrew Gove, Alan David Gray, RR Hawker, UR Herbert, P Heuff, Barry Eric Holland, M Hove, Roy Bailey Huntley, AD Hyde, L Icely, David Maurice Jackson, Hayley Theresa Jackson, H Jansen van Rensburg, Bradley Jay, R Jenkin, N Jera, O Johnson, NC Jonas, W Jonas, C Jones, SS Jwele, Imraan Kaka, Yonus Michael Kaka, Francis Ian Kerford, D Kimmelman, M Knipe, K Koen, W Labuschagne, Shane Le Breton, M Le Grange, Alison Lee, Lucinda Gaye Lees, Gary Marc Lefevre, G Levenstein, K Levenstein, Rozanne Long, E Lorimer, SC Macfie, MP Madondo, Masole Petros Maduna, S Mann, Brenda Marelen, Yonita Eliana Marto, D Mashinini, Louis Massyn, Nick Matulovich, G Maybery, Frederick John Mc Kenzie, K Meier, Shaun Alan Meiklejohn, C Mokgohlwa, Sello Mokoena, D Morrison-Jones, C Mowat, B Moyo, D Msibi, S Mthalane, Thoneshan Naidoo, Mqondisi Ngcobo, Mduduzi Maurice Nhleko, Carel Aron Nolte, Andries Albertus Oelofse, Lisa O’Reilly, Monique Peters, Bertha Pienaar, MA Pinchin, G Pocock, Stephen Damian Porteous, PD Posthumus, S Pretorius, S Price-Smith, Suellen Maria Prinsloo, C Rankin, R Rankin, S Redelinghuys, GSJ Roberts, PA Roestof, WM Roestof, B Rogers, David Rowan, M Scheepers, Brendin Scholtz, TE Schwartz, RJB Sebire, M Sims, Alison Smith, Johnny Smith, John Sneddon, Andrew Steer, Bruce William Stephenson, Rory John Steyn, L Swart, T Swiegers, S Theron, A Thoma, D Towell, KJ Townsend, K Tsineng, NG Tupper, Sibubalo Tyu, S Ulland, AW Van der Vyfer, C Van der Westhuizen, K Van Dyk, N Van Rooyen, Julie Van Wijk, Johan Van Wyk, E Veilissariou, Belinda Leigh Waghorn, G Webber, David Huntley Williams, John Gareth Williams, W Withinshaw, A Wolfaardt, Abraham Christiaam Zaayman, Nigel Zinn, L Ziphethe.

Follow Running Mann:
Share:

One Reply to “Judgement Delivered: CMA Members victorious over KZNA”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *